J.J. McCarthy Dynasty Trade Value
J.J. McCarthy dynasty trade value, rank and 30-day trend. Values as of 2026-10-13.
J.J. McCarthy dynasty outlook
J.J. McCarthy is valued at 522, ranked #238 overall and #39 of 70 QBs. The next player above him at QB is Tyson Bagent, worth 533, a gap of 11 points. Below him, Tyler Huntley sits at 512, 10 points lower. He sits in tier 32 on the FantasyCalc board. J.J. McCarthy is 23.7 years old. The QB window runs to about 32, so he has around 8 years of prime left. He has 2 seasons behind him. His dynasty value of 522 is above his redraft value of 0 by 522 (a small share), so owners price in future seasons. That long-term premium makes him a core hold for a rebuilder, while a contender can use it to buy more current production. J.J. McCarthy lost 47 points over 30 days (about 8%), so the market has cooled on him. A falling trend can mean a buying window if the decline outpaces the underlying situation, but it can also be the start of a slide. Rule of thumb: hold. Contenders should keep him unless a trade gives clear current value; rebuilders should look for a better return. Superflex note: the values here assume 1QB, so in a superflex league J.J. McCarthy is likely worth more than the board suggests, since two-QB lineups push QB prices up. J.J. McCarthy was drafted in 2024, round 1, pick 10. He came out of Michigan. He is listed with MIN.
Comparable value
| Player | Value |
|---|---|
| WR Tory Horton | 525 |
| QB Tyler Huntley | 512 |
| QB Tyson Bagent | 533 |
| WR Elijah Sarratt | 534 |
| RB Adam Randall | 508 |
| WR Skyler Bell | 545 |
Trade ideas
- 1-for-1: J.J. McCarthy for Tory Horton — test in calculator
- 1-for-2: J.J. McCarthy for Tyler Huntley + Adam Randall — test in calculator
- 1-for-1: J.J. McCarthy for Tyler Huntley — test in calculator
Open in Trade Calculator All rankings All players
FAQ
What is J.J. McCarthy's dynasty trade value?
J.J. McCarthy is valued at 522, ranking #238 overall and #39 among QBs on the FantasyCalc dynasty board (1QB, 12-team, PPR).
Is J.J. McCarthy a buy or sell in dynasty?
Hold. J.J. McCarthy is near the QB age window with a down 30-day trend, so the rule gives no clear buy or sell signal.
Who are similar dynasty assets to J.J. McCarthy?
Closest in value: Tory Horton (525), Tyler Huntley (512), Tyson Bagent (533).
Values as of 2026-10-13. Player values via FantasyCalc.